• Home
  • Login
  • Registration
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • RSS
ESLarticle.com
Tweet
  • Home
  • Articles
  • Blog
  • Members
  • Add Article

Top Categories

Teaching 509
Other 210
Classroom Management 138
Career Development 135
Learning Methodology 121
Study Skills 90
E-Learning/CALL 87
English Language Learning (ELL) 78
Teaching English as a Foreign Language (TEFL) 77
Teaching Methodology 76
English Language Teaching (ELT) 73
English as a Second Language (ESL) 64
Teach in Shanghai
Home / Articles / Learning Methodology / View Article

Publishing

  • Articles
  • Add Article
  • Articles Archive
  • Latest Articles
  • Popular Articles

Latest Articles

Jan 5, 2019

Metacognition in Reading Competency

As related to the reading process, metacognition can be defined as contemplation concerning one's own thinking processes or knowledge of one's own...

Jan 5, 2019

Mass Media Literacy Reflections for Language Instructions

"You cannot teach a man anything, you can only help him find it within himself." Galileo Galilei Mass media forms thrive today. As development...

Nov 30, 2018

Ideas for the First Class with New Learners

~~The first class with new learners can be an anxious one for all concerned – teacher as well as learners. Below are some tips to make that first...

Nov 19, 2018

10 Amazing Hacks for English Learners

10 Amazing Hacks for English Learners It is estimated that there are over a billion English speakers in the world, including native speakers,...

Nov 15, 2018

Building Reading and Writing Knowledge with Very Young Children at Hom

Education Today, December 2013 Building Reading and Writing Knowledge with Very Young Children at Home  Timothy G. Weih University of Northern...

Popular Articles

1131429 Views

5 Creative Ways to Decorate Your Classroom Bulletin Board This Winter

Back to school, fall leaves, Thanksgiving and Christmas all easily lend themselves to great decorating themes, but what to do when those are over...

370408 Views

Three Unique Ideas To Make Your Bulletin Board More Useful

Bulletin boards have long been existent in campuses. They have proven to be such versatile and useful aids in both the learning and teaching...

135693 Views

History of the Chalkboard

Walk into just about any classroom and you will find one: A dark green board on the wall, lined with pieces of chalk and felt erasers. Chalkboards,...

63212 Views

Report Card Comments

For a small minority, writing report cards isn't a big deal. But most teachers generally dread report card writing time. Completing the comment...

41591 Views

The Most Useful American Business Words

The Most Useful American Business Words: Here's a list that will come in handy for any student enrolled in an English as a Second Language (ESL)...


Learning Disability or Instructional Deficiency?

by Susan Kruger

Nov 28, 2011 Learning Methodology 3814 Views

 The more I learn about learning disabilities, the more I see that the "best practices" for educating students with learning disabilities are actually considered "best practices" for all learners. For example, math and reading interventions focus heavily on "hands-on" and "experiential" learning activities.

Isn't it well known that all students learn best when they can get actively involved in new learning topics? Why do we need special "intervention" programs to deliver this great instruction to struggling learners? Why not teach everyone this way?

I also question the label, "learning disabilities." For example, take a close look at reading; in the United States, most students are struggling. 69% of eighth-graders are reading below grade-level*. 48% of adults are not proficient readers*.

ARE THESE "LEARNING DISABILITIES" OR "INSTRUCTIONAL DEFICIENCIES?"

This though has quietly been brewing in my head for a while. It would "bubble" to my awareness every now and again but finally crystallized one day. The lightning strike came while reading an excellent book called, Uncovering the Logic of English, by Denise Eide.

Eide describes the common misconception that English is an "illogical" language. She argues that English is, in fact, very logical! The problem is that traditional reading instruction does not teach all of the rules.

I am a certified reading specialist and have been studying reading instruction for years, but most of the information in Eide's book was completely new to me. I learned several new spelling and decoding rules I had never seen before. No wonder people THINK English is not logical!

Edie provides plenty of examples to support her claim, but the following passage spoke volumes to me! If you are a parent or educator, this passage from Eide's is a MUST-READ! She provides critical information and insights for all of us...

For example, consider the phonogram (letter) [s]. Most programs teach that [s] has one sound, /s/. However, this does not account for very simple words such as is, his, has was, rise, and does. When incomplete phonics is taught, students who think more logically and literally decode is and his and /Ä­s/ and /hÄ­s/.

It is important to understand that these students are not wrong; they are doing exactly what they were told to do.

Compounding the problem is the fact that [s] is added to English nouns to form the plural. Most plurals are pronounced /z/, such as chairs, cars, houses, tables, pencils, pens, papers, etc. When the plurals are considered, [s] says /z/ 70% of the time. Certainly a sound that occurs 70% of the time is not an exception. Both sounds should be taught clearly from the beginning.

Logical/literal students are our future engineers, mathematicians, and scientists. When we tell them that [s] says /s/, they apply it to every [s] they see and quickly discover that most of the S's do not say /s/. In fact, most the letters do not sound anything like they were told. This short-circuits their logical minds. Many of these students become discouraged by English.

I am convinced this is one of the reasons that boys tend to struggle with reading more than girls. Many boys think logically and literally. Girls generally tend to be more intuitive. Logical students do not tolerate inconsistent rules. The smattering of phonics usually given to them is not only unhelpful; it is damaging. At a time in history when our economy relies on advancements in science and engineering, we cannot afford to impair these gifted citizens by not teaching them English in a manner that respects how their minds work.

At a time in history when our economy relies on advancements in science and engineering, we cannot afford to impair these gifted citizens by not teaching them English in a manner that respects how their minds work.

WE ARE SHORT-CURCUITING OUR STUDENT'S BRAINS!

I vividly remember being in 1st grade and thinking about reading, "Why even have rules? There are more exceptions than there are rules!" I remember this thought so clearly, I could take you to the room I was in and the carpet square I was staring at. I felt totally frustrated! But, of course, I thought it was "just me." "I must be missing something," I often thought.

Fast-forward 30 years and I have a beautiful and bright 7 year-old who is clearly exasperated with reading. We have spent a lot of time working through an excellent intervention program with him and I am thrilled to report that his reading is significantly improving.

But, why did we have to lose a full year of first grade battling with his school to get him the instruction he needed? Why did we have to spend thousands of dollars on formal assessments, just to get Official Paperwork to prove to his school that he was actually struggling? Why did we have to spend all of the extra time and money to provide this instruction on our own? Why isn't this explicit instruction taught to all students? It would be beneficial for everyone.

The vast majority of educators (including me, as a reading specialist) only know half the rules. By neglecting the other half of the rules, our students feel like something is wrong with them. This is very damaging.

IS "WHOLE LANGUAGE" DEAD?

Not exactly. As with most things in education (and life), we have a tendency to put things in an "either/or" silo. Either you are a republican or a democrat. It either tastes great or it is less filling. It is either whole-language or it is phonics.

The best way to teach reading, however, is to blend a balance of whole-language concepts with direct, explicit, and COMPLETE phonics instruction. Then, add a heaping tablespoon of "let's-get-fired-up-about-reading-by-finding-things-you-LOVE-to-read!"

That is the recipe for success. It's a little bit of whole-language. And a little bit of phonics. A little bit of science. And a little bit of art.

But, first, we must educate ourselves and learn what WE, too, have been missing!

*According to The National Center for Education Statistics.

Literacy is the most critical foundation for life-long learning and success, but students must also learn HOW to learn. If you would like more information on the skills students need to be successful in school and beyond, request a Toolkit that includes our popular guide, "25 Ways to Make Homework Easier...Tonight!" at our website, www.StudySkills.com. Susan Kruger is the author of the world's best-selling study skills book, SOAR Study Skills.


Article source: http://eslarticle.com/pub/learning-methodology/77750-learning-disability-or-instructional-deficiency.html

  • General Information
Author Info

Author Name: Susan Kruger

About Author: Susan Kruger is the author of SOAR Study Skills; A Simple and Efficient System for Earning Better Grades in Less Time. Get Susan\\\'s FREE Homework Rx Toolkit, featuring 25 Ways to Make Homework Easier...Tonight!, at her website: http://soarstudyskills.co

Most Recent Articles

  • Mar 10, 2018 Cooperative Learning - Exploring Hidden Possibilities by Susan Kruger
  • Jan 2, 2018 Cooperative Learning - Exploring Hidden Possibilities by Susan Kruger
  • Nov 14, 2017 Chomsky Versus Piaget: Innatism or Constructivism? by Susan Kruger
  • Dec 25, 2016 How To Get Straight "A"s by Susan Kruger
  • Oct 15, 2016 The Facts About Collaborative Learning by Susan Kruger

Actions

  • Print Page

Articles Archive

  • April 2021
  • February 2021
  • January 2021
  • December 2020
  • November 2020
  • October 2020

Random Articles

Learning Methodology

Brainwaves Explained

The brain is powered by electromagnetic energy. Whether we are mentally active, resting or asleep, the brain always has electrical activity. By...

Pronunciation/Phonics

English Pronunciation - Word Stress

Pronunciation is an important aspect of learning English. If you learn the incorrect pronunciation of a word, you may not understand it when...

About ESL Article

ESL Article is a private ESL/TEFL site designed and maintained by educators and educational administrators. It was launched in August 2008 with the aim of bringing ESL/TEFL students, parents, teachers and schools information and articles about the teaching profession and learning community.

Icon Group Member

ESL Article is a member of Icon Group Thailand (IGT), a group of ESL TEFL TESOL websites providing educational resources and information to teachers, schools and students around the world. The group was founded in 2003 and now includes 15+ websites covering educational information services, teaching resources and e-learning.

What is ESL?

English as a second language (ESL) is the use or study of English by speakers of different native languages. It is also known as English for speakers of other languages (ESOL), English as an additional language (EAL), and English as a foreign language (EFL).

  • Home
  • Registration
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Help
  • Partner
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
​

© 2021 ESLarticle.com.
Member of Icon Group Thailand - Educating the Future:
TESall All TESOL  Total ESL  ESL Job Feed
TEFL World  TEFL Jobs Overseas  Teach Overseas
Asia TEFL  ESL Powerpoint  Teacher Training